The valuation says the building is worth a certain figure. It does not say who could pay it or how long finding them would take.
That is usually settled on the day of purchase, when nobody is thinking about selling. The size you commit sets how many buyers you will have when you want to leave.
Entry gets the attention. The asset is inspected, the sponsor is questioned, the structure is reviewed. Exit is left as an assumption: a good asset will find a buyer when the time comes. For a small position, that is a reasonable assumption. For a large position, it deserves a test.
Depth Changes With Size
Markets are not equally deep at every ticket size. An apartment can usually find a private buyer, because many people can afford it. A whole building is different. The buyers able to take it are a smaller group: funds with a mandate at that size, family offices with room in their allocation, a handful of well-capitalised owners. Each has a financing position, a timetable and an appetite that depends on conditions of its own.
“Large” here is relative. What matters is your position against typical trades in its segment, not its absolute size.
The value of a position rises in proportion to its size. The number of buyers able to take it does the opposite: it shrinks as the size rises.
Several things narrow the field. Buyers have concentration limits, so they pass on a position that would be a large share of their allocation. Larger deals need longer due diligence and committee approval, which makes the sale slower and more exposed to a change in conditions along the way. And financing for large assets comes from fewer lenders, whose appetite moves with the cycle.
Headline activity can hide all this. A market can trade very large volumes in a year and still have few buyers at the size you hold, because much of that activity happens at sizes you are not selling. Activity tells you that deals are happening. It does not tell you whether a deal of your size could.
What a Thin Field Costs
A thin field costs you in three ways and the valuation shows only one of them.
Time. A market valuation assumes the asset has been properly marketed for a reasonable period. A large position usually needs a longer period, because fewer buyers must be found, approved and financed. If you need to sell sooner, the price you can reach in the shorter window can sit well below the valuation. And a longer sale leaves you exposed to the market for longer, so a sale meant to take a few months can end up closing in a different market from the one that was valued.
Price. This is the part everyone expects. A buyer who can see your deadline will price it in.
Terms. Where only a few buyers can proceed, they can ask for more than a price: part of the payment deferred, adjustments after closing, conditions that give them a way out. A headline figure can hide how much of it you actually receive and when.
A valuation gives one number. Time and terms do not appear in it.
Follow a Position From Purchase to Sale
Walk a single building through its life in your portfolio.
You buy it as a core holding. The seller will only sell it whole, the yield is attractive and you are comfortable with the asset. The building becomes a large share of your property exposure. Neither the seller nor the valuation asks who could buy it back.
Some years later you need cash for a reason unrelated to the building. The latest valuation is supportive and you expect a sale within a few months.
Then the buyers turn out to be few. A fund that might have bid is fully allocated for the year. Another can proceed only if its lender agrees terms and lending conditions have tightened. A third will bid, but below the valuation and with part of the price deferred, because it can see you have a deadline. The sale takes months longer than planned.
You made no visible mistake. You paid a fair price for a sound asset and the valuation was honest throughout. The delay, the discount and the conditions were all set on the day you chose the size. Had you bought half or held it in two parts that could be sold separately, more buyers could have taken part.
What to Do Differently
- Place your position among typical deals in its segment. Is it a size that many buyers can afford or that only a few can? Ask your adviser or valuer for transactions of this size over the last 36 months. If none can be produced, you have learned that the depth is unknown, which is not the same as deep.
- Name the realistic buyers and what each would need. By type and by number: a fund with room in its allocation, a family office with a mandate for this kind of asset, an owner next door with a reason to expand. For each, ask what must be true for them to buy, such as mandate, allocation and financing. If you can name only one buyer, you have one.
- Ask your valuer about time and terms, not only price. How long would a sale at this size normally take? What would the price be if you needed to sell in half that time? The gap between the two answers is the cost of your size.
- Size and structure to the answers. An asset can be attractive and still too large for the buyers who could take it back. Consider buying less or splitting the exposure across holdings that can be sold separately. Direct co-ownership, shares in a holding company, joint venture interests and fund units can each allow partial exits and each has its own limits, such as consent rights, lock-ups or transfer restrictions. Dividing a holding does not create buyers. It widens the group that could become buyers, so the second step still applies.
None of this argues against large positions. Some of the best investments are large and concentration is sometimes the right choice. The point is to choose the size knowing what the exit will take.
The Objection Worth Taking Seriously
The usual reply is that global capital will always find a good asset. There is truth in that. In active periods, buyers from many places compete for quality and a large position can sell well.
The question is whether they will be present when you need them. The buyers who can write a large cheque are also exposed to conditions: funding costs, their own allocation limits, their view of the cycle. Depth is easy to find when conditions are generous and that is when it is least needed. The test is how the field looks when conditions are not good.
And an investor who plans never to sell still faces the question. A refinancing that falls through, an estate to divide or a family need can each force a sale on someone else’s timetable.
Could you name three realistic buyers for a position of your size?
